IPMN new web banner

IPMN Responds to Christian Century on "Positive Investment"

To:  Christian Century
Re:  “Investing in Palestinians”

Anyone who hears the phrase “positive investment” very reasonably thinks:  “How can you be against that?”  But, as in many human situations and conflicts, the devil is in the details.

“Positive Investment” assumes that there is a context in which it can actually work.  So far, self-proclaimed proponents have found some possible inroads to this kind of investment in the IT field but not much beyond that.  That is wonderful and we hope this development continues.  Beyond the virtual, however, exactly how do olive farmers move actual products past walls and checkpoints and Israeli-only highways; that is, beyond the “Swiss cheese” of the Bantustans created by barriers that run deep into the Occupied Palestinian Territories cutting Palestinians off from each other?  Many farmers are separated from their ancestral lands and cannot even harvest their olives or tend their trees. They are dependent upon many Christians from the U.S. and elsewhere to come and do it for them.  The best “positive” investment would be to allow the owners and growers of those crops to actually get to them rather than have their land be confiscated by the Israeli government for lack of production.

Palestinians themselves know that the economics of BDS (boycott, divestment and sanctions) will hit them hard. So what is the logic of them writing the Kairos Palestine Document signed by all Christian leaders and even endorsed by many Palestinian Muslim leaders calling for BDS? It comes out of the pain and struggle of living under occupation, which Bishop Tutu himself has said is in some ways worse than the apartheid he experienced in South Africa.  Divestment there helped change the course of history by non-violent means.  And like South Africa, the call for church divestment is from corporations profiting from human pain and suffering.

Presbyterians are already accustomed to not investing in companies that provide materiel used in conflict.  Divestment by our church has always been about aligning our finances with our faith and values.  At the very least, concerned Christians have every right to ask that their local congregational budgets and their pensions do not grow as a result of this kind of pain and suffering, whether anything changes on the ground or not. The call for Presbyterian divestment comes only after years of corporate engagement where the companies named have made it clear they will not cooperate with the church’s standards for positive investment. The truth is: there are dozens of companies operating in Israel from which our denomination need never divest because their products are for inherently peaceful pursuits.

Israel’s military occupation locks an entire people behind concrete walls, creates suffering and even death among the Palestinian people far outnumbering the terrible Israeli losses.  It prevents any realistic chance for effective positive “investment in Palestinians” and a viable free enterprise economy.

The first step is to actually go to Palestine and see how life is captive behind the walls and checkpoints; to see how actual goods (as opposed to virtual products) have no prayer of crossing lines and barriers; and to hear about the pain and suffering that comes with the collective punishment imposed for simply being Palestinian.

On behalf of
The Israel Palestine Mission Network of the PC(USA)

Jeffrey DeYoe, Advocacy Chair
Ft. Myers, Florida

IPMN Tweets

⁦@PresbyHistory⁩ LIVE: Sarah Smith's Educational Advocacy for Arab Women Thursday Mar4 zoom at 5ET https://t.co/FXnkOE44Th
RT @IfNotNowOrg: We are disappointed to see @RepTedDeutch advocating for a definition of antisemitism that has been used to curb the free s…
RT @IfNotNowOrg: Let's be clear: The IHRA working definition of antisemitism is a tool of the far-right, and does nothing to keep our commu…
@ShereefElnahal very sad to see you hold up Israel’s medical apartheid as a model for the US. Please watch this ver… https://t.co/NHuVpaPRz5
More than 250 Australian and international scholars are calling on a prominent Australian historian to reconsider a… https://t.co/fRQv05JFdm
Scholars call on Australian historian to decline Israeli award | The $1 million prize is awarded by a foundation ba… https://t.co/wPYem1sVZR
Follow IPMN of PCUSA on Twitter