IPMN new web banner

Anna Baltzer's counsel to GA cmt 15 on behalf of ACREC

 

Anna Baltzer, Resource Person 

Speaking on behalf of The Advocacy Committee for Racial Ethnic Concerns (ACREC)

(a permanent committee of the General Assembly)

baltzeranna

Testimony Regarding Divestment

Middle East Peacemaking Committee

220th General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (USA)

Monday, July 2, 2012


Thank you, Mr. Moderator.

I defer to the Mission Responsibility Through Investment committee to answer your questions regarding the internal process of engagement with the companies leading to the recommendation to divest. Coming from my perspective as a Jewish American who has lived in Palestine, I can speak to the two other main concerns I have heard regarding Jewish-Christian relations and investment being a positive alternative to divestment.

Friends, I am not up here as a Jew to tell that it’s okay for you to divest. Because you do not need my permission to do whatever you think is the righteous thing to do. You don’t need anybody’s permission.

I realize that divestment is controversial. That’s okay. Slavery was controversial. The Church was divided. Desegregation was controversial. Especially in the South, people were afraid of damaging relationships if they spoke out for desegregation. But the Presbyterian Church supported an end to segregation before it was common. I urge you to honor that legacy by acting today out of love and compassion rather than fear of what others will say.

You are being told that action against the occupation will estrange you from the Jewish people. But the occupation is fundamentally contrary to our shared values of equality and justice.

There is nothing Jewish about racial profiling with Hewlett Packard bioscanners.

There is nothing Jewish about protecting stolen land with Motorola technology.

There is nothing Jewish about demolishing Palestinian homes with Caterpillar bulldozers.

And to claim that ending cooperation with these human rights violations means ending cooperation with Judaism, or Jews, draws a very dangerous parallel. There is a sea change happening. Jews are divided on this issue. You have to follow your own conscience.

Regarding the idea of investment as a positive alternative to divestment, let me point out first that there is nothing neutral about profiting from the destruction of Palestinian homes and schools, as you are today. To stop profiting from those things, to divest, is not negative -- it’s positive.

Investment can also be positive, but it should be practical. No Palestinian economy can endure without access to land, water, goods, or labor. Checkpoints using HP bioscanners prevent workers from reaching work or transporting products. Settlements surrounded by Motorola cameras make it impossible for Palestinians to reach their land and resources. And anything you build can be destroyed in a flash with Caterpillar bulldozers.

For 170 years, your church has chosen the model of mission in partnership rather than missionary work, recognizing the importance of listening to the voices and choices of those you are trying to help. Why do mission in partnership in Africa and South America, but not in the land where Jesus walked?

Right now, the Palestinians are not asking for you to invest in their economy. They are asking you to stop investing in and profiting from their suffering. They are asking you to engage in divestment, a time-tested, nonviolent, faithful act of love.

Giving charity can also be loving. But dismissing Palestinian voices is not loving… It’s patronizing.

If you truly want to help the Palestinian people, I urge you to listen to what they are asking for.

Thank you.

Anna Baltzer
National Organizer
US Campaign to End the Israeli Occupation
2017 Mission St, 2nd Floor; San Francisco, CA 94110
Main office: PO Box 21539; Washington, D.C. 20009

IPMN Tweets

IPMN of PCUSA
Is this what countries claiming to be democracies do? Isn't free speech a fundamental principle of democracy? "Is… https://t.co/6CAfxkgDTk
IPMN of PCUSA
"Battle underway in Ireland over ban on settlement goods" https://t.co/KrW1uutvLL
IPMN of PCUSA
Is it really always about oil? "Oil’s enduring sway over U.S. policy in the Middle East, and how it explains the… https://t.co/ZjMvE1pPrr
IPMN of PCUSA
Americans don't view Palestinians as subhuman, as he claims. They have no idea what the Israelis are doing to Pales… https://t.co/e2Xue86GdN
IPMN of PCUSA
It is unfathomable that those in #Gaza have to live under this threat daily.....https://t.co/ZIC3DLdvgX #EndGazaBlockage #EndGazaViolence
IPMN of PCUSA
Why is the Jordan Valley so important to Israel? https://t.co/WvOxiCmPmb via @AlMonitor
Follow IPMN of PCUSA on Twitter